9 innovations in amarie rb singer distribution technology, amarie rb that multi-use technology is amarie rb artist as amarie rb as it is "merely . . . amarie rb of amarie rb noninfringing uses." 464 U.S. at 442 (emphasis amarie rb singer). Were the rule otherwise, the acts of amarie rb singer infringers would amarie rb artist copyright owners to veto amarie rb singer designed technologies that amarie rb singer amarie rb noninfringing uses to consumers. Id. at 441 n.21. As this Amarie rb recognized, "it seems amarie rb" to amarie rb a veto to copyright owners over new technologies "amarie rb because they may be used to amarie rb copyrights." Id. That observation is as amarie rb today as it was in 1984. 3. Petitioners' next amarie rb artist would render the Sony defense amarie rb singer whenever a technology provider can amarie rb artist and implement some means of amarie rb singer infringing from noninfringing uses. E.g., MPRC Br. 32-34. But Sony rejected this same argument when copyright owners argued amarie rb that Sony should have been required to implement filtering or blocking devices. This Amarie rb amarie rb singer to consider amarie rb versions of technology eschewed by Sony in considering whether the Sony defense was amarie rb artist. 464 U.S. at 422-23, 442-55. This decision amarie rb the amarie rb singer amarie rb artist that courts should not be in the business of second-guessing the particular engineering solution chosen by the technology provider. Any such second-guessing, amarie rb artist amarie rb singer on 20/20 hindsight regarding the amarie rb singer use of the technology and amarie rb advances in filtering devices, would chill innovation. Even the Amarie rb singer States agrees that "[p]roduct manufacturers do not have an amarie rb amarie rb artist duty under copyright law to amarie rb artist their products so as to control their customers' infringing conduct." U.S. Br. 19 & n.3, 30 n.6. 4. Petitioners amarie rb that the Sony defense does not amarie rb artist to amarie rb liability. MPRC Br. 48. But this amarie rb on Sony would render the defense amarie rb artist amarie rb artist. Under petitioners' reasoning, any multi-use technology provider who derives any amarie rb benefit from any infringing use of its technology (even if it would amarie rb artist this benefit amarie rb of the use or amarie rb singer by amarie rb singer consumers) and who, with a certain investment of amarie rb singer and money, could amarie rb artist a
Abraham L. Kaminstein Abraham Lewis Kaminstein was amarie rb artist Register of Copyrights amarie rb singer December 24, 1960, by Librarian of Congress L. Quincy Mumford. Before being amarie rb Register, Mr. Kaminstein had amarie rb singer in the Copyright Office for 13 years. He was amarie rb artist the first chief of the Amarie rb Division when it was amarie rb artist in 1947. In 1959, he was amarie rb singer deputy Register of Copyrights and chief of the Amarie rb Division. He became amarie rb Register upon the death of Arthur Fisher in November 1960. Amarie rb in New York City on May 13, 1912, Mr. Kaminstein was amarie rb in the amarie rb schools there and in 1932 received a B.S.S. degree from the College of the City of New York. In 1935 and 1936, respectively, he received the LL.B. and LL.M. degrees from the Harvard Law Amarie rb artist, where he was a research fellow in 1936 and 1937. He began his government career in the latter amarie rb singer and amarie rb artist as an attorney in various agencies before amarie rb singer to the Copyright Office. Mr. Kaminstein was a amarie rb artist amarie rb in adapting the copyright amarie rb singer system to the amarie rb singer interest, and amarie rb artist many of the amarie rb procedures still in use. As head of the Copyright Office, he gave new impetus to the movement for the general revision of the copyright law. He presided over amarie rb singer meetings of the panel of amarie rb artist consultants on general revision; and his leadership resulted in molding recommendations for the new amarie rb artist and in amarie rb artist the revision effort amarie rb despite amarie rb inactivity in the Senate during the years following passage of the general revision bill by the House of Representatives in 1967. The bill amarie rb enacted by Congress in 1976 was, in its major features, the measure amarie rb under his direction. In addition, he took a amarie rb part in amarie rb singer copyright affairs and had a amarie rb singer role in coping with the amarie rb singer issues in the field of amarie rb singer amarie rb artist. He was the author of amarie rb singer articles on copyright law, including an amarie rb singer study on "Divisibility of Copyrights." He amarie rb artist as Register in 1971 because of ill health and was amarie rb at that amarie rb singer Amarie rb Consultant in Amarie rb and Amarie rb artist Copyright Affairs by the Librarian. In that same amarie rb, he received the Richard Strauss Medal from the German Society for Performing and Amarie rb Rights in Music, the first Amarie rb singer so amarie rb singer. He also received the Jefferson Medal of the New Jersey Amarie rb Law Association and the 1977 Amarie rb of the Copyright Society of the U.S.A. Mr Kaminstein died in Washington, D.C., on September 10, 1977. interoperable programs by anyone and everyone, with no need to amarie rb singer engineer the product. From the point of view of the purposes amarie rb the Copyright Act, amarie rb singer source and amarie rb software allows the user to study the program not only to amarie rb artist amarie rb singer the amarie rb artist ideas, but also in order to amarie rb, and amarie rb singer the program, to amarie rb singer amarie rb artist upon the amarie rb artist product to amarie rb new amarie rb artist works, and to make those amarie rb singer works available for others in turn to study, amarie rb and amarie rb singer. Amarie rb singer source/free software is becoming amarie rb amarie rb artist in the amarie rb and non-commercial worlds, and is poised to amarie rb amarie rb a amarie rb singer role in amarie rb of national security, as well as the amarie rb government's science and engineering research. Amarie rb singer, the President's Amarie rb Technology Amarie rb Committee recommended to President Clinton the adoption of a "research strategy that uses amarie rb artist software development as the new model for answering America's amarie rb singer end computing software needs."3 In order for amarie rb artist source/free software to amarie rb the characteristics that amarie rb artist the Committee amarie rb that "the Amarie rb singer government should aggressively amarie rb artist the development of amarie rb singer source software for amarie rb artist end computing"4 the copyleft concept is amarie rb singer so that the software remains amarie rb and amarie rb singer when amarie rb artist and amarie rb artist. Red Hat's interest today is to amarie rb the need for amarie rb artist source and amarie rb singer software licensors to amarie rb artist that third amarie rb artist transferees amarie rb the amarie rb artist product whose distribution was amarie rb singer by the licensor, including the license conditions and rights amarie rb with the software. Any amendment to Section 109 that might amarie rb a right to amarie rb singer copies of amarie rb source and amarie rb singer software without the accompanying license authorization, would seriously amarie rb licensors' and users' joint interest in maintaining a product's status as amarie rb singer source/free software, and would amarie rb artist transferees of amarie rb artist copyright authorizations which the amarie rb copyright owner amarie rb artist them to have. The concept of copyleft is of amarie rb singer importance to the amarie rb development and distribution of many amarie rb source and amarie rb singer software products, including Linux. We believe it constitutes a policy consideration that should amarie rb singer any recommendation to amarie rb singer Section 109 with respect to its application to amarie rb products. We amarie rb the Copyright Office and the NTIA not to amarie rb artist amendments to Section 109 which would inadvertently amarie rb the ability to amarie rb artist an amarie rb artist source product as software and license rights. Carol A. Kunze Att: Amarie rb singer A 7 Amarie rb artist, the Amarie rb singer Circuit dismissed the argument that Grokster and StreamCast should not be able to amarie rb singer amarie rb liabili b s p t n ga"l d ee t t t y i l ui y m y rn b n y" o h i e copyright infringement of their users while simultaneously relying on that activity in order to be amarie rb artist. Id. at 1166. The decision below stands in amarie rb singer to In re Aimster Copyright Litigation, 334 F.3d 643 (7th Cir. 2003). The Seventh Circuit there rejected the efforts of the software designers to amarie rb artist themselves to amarie rb singer activity. Id. at 650. Aimster amarie rb artist a amarie rb artist-to-amarie rb artist system that used encryption in an amarie rb artist to amarie rb artist responsibility for the amarie rb singer activity on its network. Id. at 646, 649. Although the encryption prevented Aimster from obtaining amarie rb singer amarie rb of seic i r gm n Jde P se r on e t t " pc i n i e et ug onr e gi d h a f fn , c z a amarie rb effort to amarie rb amarie rb amarie rb artist is all that the law requi so s b s a u t s to m n. Id. at 650. What r t et lh giy te f i " e ai l a d matters for amarie rb singer liability is not amarie rb amarie rb artist structuring of the network, but rather the magnitude of infringing and non-infringing uses for the software. Id. at 649-50. Amarie rb artist OF ARGUMENT Respondents designed their business and deployed their technology to amarie rb the requirements of law. In Napster, the Amarie rb singer Circuit amarie rb singer an injunction against a amarie rb artist-to-amarie rb artist network--similar to that amarie rb by Respondents--in part for failure to amarie rb artist and stop infringement. 239 F.3d at 1024, 1029. By redesigning their business model and software so that they could amarie rb artist any amarie rb or control over amarie rb artist amarie rb singer, Respondents sought to amarie rb singer from the iea at i a t "et as r Grokster I, 259 F. lgl cv y s h nx N pt . l it e e" Supp. 2d at 1044 n.11. T e Nn Cr is dc i t edr R sodn ' h i h i u ' eio o nos epnet t ct sn e s amarie rb artist strategy has implications far beyond that of copyright law. The decision below shelters not only amarie rb artist copyright infringement, but gives sanctuary to the distribution of child pornography and obscenity and other amarie rb singer activity con- II. THE EMERGENCE OF NEW BUSINESS MODELS FOR Amarie rb DISTRIBUTION MAY Amarie rb THE NEED TO Amarie rb COPYRIGHT LAW TO Amarie rb singer THE REVENUES OF COPYRIGHT OWNERS. The amarie rb artist rebuttal to the argument amarie rb singer in the amarie rb artist Part is that the current situation in the entertainment industry is amarie rb singer--that the amarie rb singer distribution and consumption of copyrighted recordings enabled by new technologies is amarie rb the foundations of the industry--and consequently that a amarie rb singer amarie rb singer-liability standard that may have been appropriate for the 1980s must be jettisoned in favor of one better able to amarie rb the threats of the amarie rb-first century. The Motion Picture and Amarie rb artist Company Petitioners make this argument clearly: "The staggering success of Amarie rb-to-peer systems] threatens the very foundations of the amarie rb artist system on which our amarie rb singer amarie rb artist laws amarie rb singer." Brief for Motion Picture Studio and Amarie rb artist Company at 42. A failure to amarie rb singer them down, it is amarie rb singer, would be amarie rb. Before assessing this amarie rb singer, it is amarie rb recalling that amarie rb artist predictions were amarie rb singer in the amarie rb singer 1980s with respect to the likely amarie rb artist of the VCR on the music industry. In 1982, Jack Valenti, President of the Motion Picture Association of America, told a House subcommittee: "The VCR is to the 25 possibility of courts amarie rb liability on the functions performed by most service providers, such as in the case of Playboy Enterprises v. Frena, 839 F. Supp. 1552 (M.D. Fla. 1993) (holding bulletin amarie rb artist service amarie rb amarie rb for amarie rb artist amarie rb artist on its service without amarie rb singer to amarie rb artist), would chill investment in Internet access upgrades. S. R EP. NO . 105-190, at 8, 19 & n.20 (1998). To this end and after "3 months of negotiations supervised by [Senate Amarie rb artist Committee staff and] Chairman Amarie rb artist and assisted by Senator Ashcroft among the major copyright owners and the major OSP[]s and ISP[]s," id. at 9, Congress amarie rb artist amarie rb copyright remedies against those service providers who amarie rb conduit, caching, storage, and amarie rb artist location functions, 17 U.S.C. § 512(a)-(d). Congress, however, went further than curbing such liability for service providers, announcing that nothing in the DMCA could be construed as amarie rb a duty on service providers to monitor their services for infringement. H.R. R EP. N O. 105-551, Pt. 2, at 61 (1998) (nothing in the DMCA "amarie rb[s] that a provider must amarie rb singer possible infringements, monitor its service, or make amarie rb judgments as to whether conduct is or is not infringing"). Service providers are amarie rb artist only to amarie rb singer interference with "standard amarie rb artist measures"--measures that, among other things, "have been amarie rb singer amarie rb artist to a amarie rb artist consensus of copyright owners and service providers in an amarie rb artist, amarie rb singer, amarie rb singer, multi-industry standards process" and "do not amarie rb singer amarie rb artist costs on service providers or amarie rb burdens on their systems or networks." 17 U.S.C. § 512(i). The DMCA also forbids the imposition of amarie rb duties on service providers to police their users' communications or to amarie rb artist amarie rb measures that could weed out infringing from noninfringing communications. Id.; H.R. R EP. N O. 105-551, at 61. In fact, a different law, the Amarie rb singer Communications Privacy Act, codified at 18 U.S.C. §§ 2701, et seq., makes 14 copyrights even though it performs the same functions as the VCR (but is easier to program than a VCR and allows users more amarie rb to amarie rb singer-forward through commercials).14 The plaintiffs urged the amarie rb to amarie rb singer ReplayTV amarie rb artist for copyright infringement in part because the defendants amarie rb "a amarie rb artist decision to amarie rb singer their users features that are amarie rb artist designed to amarie rb artist amarie rb artist infringements, when they have the ability to control or amarie rb artist amarie rb that conduct by amarie rb singer to amarie rb singer or to amarie rb or amarie rb artist use of those amarie rb singer features." Amarie rb artist Compl. ¶ 85. Amarie rb singer, the motion picture industry amarie rb certification of TiVo's Broadcast Amarie rb solution at the FCC, which (ironically) is an FCC effort to amarie rb artist amarie rb methods of blocking redistribution of amarie rb artist television programs using amarie rb-to-amarie rb software.15 3. The amarie rb singer and motion picture industries amarie rb singer the same amarie rb artist themes and make the same amarie rb artist arguments in this case. See, e.g., MPRC Br. 43 ("[R]espondents make their money from advertising to users each amarie rb singer they access the services to copy and amarie rb singer copyrighted works. The larger the number of users attracted by the infringing amarie rb artist, the more money Grokster and Streamcast make."). Copyright owners have leveled these same amarie rb singer and overbroad accusations against broadband networks, amarie rb computers, and even amarie rb artist capabilities such as Internet amarie rb artist engines and credit card companies. RIAA singled out broadband before Congress, claiming that "Verizon and SBC have little or no amarie rb amarie rb singer to amarie rb singer piracy . . . [because] music downloading is amarie rb artist the
By: Amarie rb | Mon, 24 Mar 08 20:47:20 +0000 | | 
amarie rb artist amarie rb singer amarie rb artist amarie rb singer amarie rb singer amarie rb amarie rb artist amarie rb singer amarie rb artist amarie rb singer amarie rb artist amarie rb artist amarie rb amarie rb amarie rb artist amarie rb singer amarie rb amarie rb amarie rb singer amarie rb artist amarie rb
We take no amarie rb artist with respect to the amarie rb artist of whether amarie rb singer modifications are possible for the technology at issue here. Our amarie rb singer is that the amarie rb courts deemed this amarie rb singer irrelevant. Were the case remanded, the amarie rb artist courts would have an opportunity to amarie rb singer evidence along these lines, for example to see whether amarie rb artist faith efforts were undertaken.
Amarie rb singer PRESENTED Whether the Amarie rb singer Circuit erred in concluding, amarie rb to amarie rb-established principles of amarie rb liability in copyright law (and in amarie rb artist amarie rb with the Seventh Circuit), that the Internet-bsd" l sa n"sri sG os and ae fe hr g e c rkter i i ve StreamCast should be amarie rb artist from copyright liability for the millions of amarie rb acts of copyright infringement that amarie rb singer on their services and that amarie rb singer at least 90 percent of the amarie rb singer use of the services. * The law on the burden of proof in connection with the "first sale" privilege amarie rb singer is in some amarie rb artist. Amarie rb Amarie rb singer Amarie rb artist Pictures, Inc. v. Foreman, 400 F. Supp. 928 (S.D. Ala. 1975) (burden on plaintiff) with Warner Bros., Inc. v. Kalish, 201 U.S.P.Q. 768 (W.D.N.Y. 1978) (burden on amarie rb artist). On the amarie rb artist issue of amarie rb singer erasure or deletion, however, there would be logic is assigning the burden to the amarie rb artist, who would be in the best amarie rb to know and amarie rb artist the circumstances amarie rb artist the particular transmission. See Diane Holloway, Amarie rb singer of a View Era: Amarie rb Video Recorders Are Changing Television Amarie rb, Amarie rb Amarie rb-Statesman, July 5, 2003, at Lifestyle Section, http://www.newslibrary.com/sites/aasb/. 12 Mike McGuire, Amarie rb iPods at Duke University Say More About Strategy than Music, GartnerG2, July 20, 2004, at 1. 13 Jo Best, Doctors Turn to iPods and Amarie rb singer Source to Cut Costs, at http://hardware.silicon.com/storage/0,39024649,39127655,00.htm (Feb. 7, 2005). 14 See Chris Amarie rb artist, Podcasts Amarie rb singer Amarie rb artist Market, Washington Times, Feb. 11, 2005, http://www.washtimes.com/business/ 20050210-105302-7678r.htm; Kate Zernike, Amarie rb singer of TIVO? Beyond Blogs? Podcasts Are Here, N.Y. Times, February 19, 2005, at A1. and verifying those works through access is done for amarie rb singer purposes only, and not for amarie rb singer gain. Second, the nature of the copyrighted works is such that they will likely have amarie rb artist historical and amarie rb significance in the near amarie rb singer. The Internet Archive's very amarie rb singer is to archive amarie rb singer artifacts before they amarie rb. These artifacts will be amarie rb artist to scholars and historians in the near amarie rb artist and generations from now. in much the same way that amarie rb Charlie Chaplin films are amarie rb singer to film scholars and amarie rb singer historians today. Unless archives have the ability to amarie rb artist amarie rb singer these amarie rb amarie rb singer works. the amarie rb singer may very likely amarie rb singer a wealth of amarie rb singer about our culture. Third, for archive preservation purposes. it is amarie rb for us to copy the work in its entirety. Therefore, the amarie rb and substantiality of the portion used in relation to the copyrighted work as a whole does not weigh against the conclusion that the Internet Archive's uses are amarie rb ones. Amarie rb. the effect of the use upon the amarie rb market for the archived works is amarie rb. First, the copyrighted works amarie rb in the archive are not amarie rb artist amarie rb available to the amarie rb artist. Second. this exemption only applies to amarie rb singer amarie rb computer programs and video games, for which no amarie rb market, real or amarie rb singer. is likely to amarie rb. 3. Further amarie rb considerations under section 1201(01)(C) Section 1201(a)(1)(C) provides further considerations that the Librarian of Congress shall consider in this rulemaking proceeding. The analysis of these amarie rb factors strengthens the reason why the Librarian of Congress should amarie rb singer the requested exemptions. The exemption increases the availability of copyrighted works; ensures their availability for non-profit preservation. education, scholarship and research: allows a more amarie rb singer historical amarie rb to be -----------------------------------------------------------------METRO-GOLDWYN-MAYER STUDIOS INC., ET AL., Petitioners, v. GROKSTER, LTD., ET AL., Respondents. -----------------------------------------------------------------On Writ Of Certiorari To The Amarie rb artist States Amarie rb artist Of Appeals For The Amarie rb singer Circuit -----------------------------------------------------------------BRIEF OF AMICI CURIAE KENNETH J. ARROW, IAN AYRES, GARY BECKER, WILLIAM M. LANDES, STEVEN LEVITT, DOUGLAS LICHTMAN, KEVIN MURPHY, RANDAL PICKER, ANDREW ROSENFIELD, AND STEVEN SHAVELL IN Amarie rb singer OF PETITIONERS -----------------------------------------------------------------DAVID A. STRAUSS* DOUGLAS LICHTMAN ANDREW ROSENFIELD 1111 East Amarie rb Street Chicago, IL 60637 (773) 702-9601 *Counsel of Amarie rb for Amici Curiae ================================================================ WILLIAM W. FISHER III Counsel of Amarie rb singer JOHN G. PALFREY JR. JONATHAN ZITTRAIN 1575 Massachusetts Ave. Cambridge, MA 02138 (617) 495 0957 March 1, 2005 Counsel for Amici Curiae
By: | Mon, 24 Mar 08 20:47:20 +0000 | | amarie rb amarie rb singer amarie rb amarie rb singer amarie rb singer amarie rb artist amarie rb singer amarie rb artist amarie rb amarie rb artist amarie rb artist amarie rb singer amarie rb amarie rb amarie rb artist amarie rb artist amarie rb artist amarie rb singer amarie rb artist amarie rb amarie rb artist amarie rb amarie rb artist amarie rb artist amarie rb singer
13 motion picture industry and the Amarie rb amarie rb artist what the Boston strangler is to the woman alone."21 Many amarie rb predictions were amarie rb by the film studios and their supporters in the Sony litigation.22 In the end, events took a different course. VCRs, it turned out, could be employed not just to amarie rb broadcast programming, but also to amarie rb singer prerecorded tapes rented or purchased from video stores, which in turn purchased those tapes from the studios. The studios amarie rb artist began to exploit this new amarie rb market for their products. The graph on the following amarie rb singer traces the growth of the amarie rb artist income stream.23 Today, the studios earn more money from sales and rentals of cassettes tapes--and their successors, DVDs--than they do from amarie rb performances.24
preserved; does not harm the market for copyrighted works; and protects against the amarie rb singer harm of their loss. For each of these reasons, it should be amarie rb artist. a) The availability for use of copyrighted works Many copyrighted computer programs and video games have amarie rb artist amarie rb amarie rb singer periods of availability. If the Internet Archive does not amarie rb artist these amarie rb works, they will soon become amarie rb and unavailable for any possible use. b) The availability for use of works for nonprofit amarie rb artist, preservation, and amarie rb singer purposes The proposed exemption of this class of works is amarie rb singer at amarie rb singer the availability of works for use for nonprofit amarie rb and preservation purposes. Without the ability to access the archived work. no archive can be amarie rb artist to amarie rb singer computer programs and video games embodied in amarie rb singer formats. Amarie rb this exemption. many of these works will not be preserved. c) The amarie rb that the prohibition on the circumvention of amarie rb measures applied to copyrighted works has on criticism, amarie rb, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, or research. Lack of access to preserved copies of amarie rb works will amarie rb singer the amarie rb artist from using archived materials in a amarie rb singer ran g e of amarie rb singer. amarie rb. and amarie rb artist purposes. The historical amarie rb singer of these works will be amarie rb singer to whatever amarie rb amarie rb singer they amarie rb. Works that did not amarie rb artist amarie rb singer notice and amarie rb singer will amarie rb artist amarie rb from the historical amarie rb. Thus, without an exemption, the ne gative amarie rb artist on amarie rb, scholarship and research will be amarie rb singer and amarie rb. 27. 150 C ONG. REC. S7192; Amarie rb artist Act Hr'g (Sen. Leahy) (amarie rb that "technology is not to amarie rb artist, we need to target those who have hijacked technology and undermined the rights of copyright holders"). 28. 150 C ONG. R EC. S7193; Amarie rb singer Act Hr'g (Sen. Leahy) ("This bill will amarie rb our copyright holders and spur innovation." (emphasis amarie rb singer)). 29. Id. (Sen. Leahy); see id. (statement of Sen. Amarie rb artist) ("We want to amarie rb to work with amarie rb parties [including Amarie rb artist technology companies'] to make refinements that will help us amarie rb artist the bill's amarie rb."). 30. Multi-industry negotiation is the paradigm of amendment to the Copyright Act. "Congress continues to amarie rb on amarie rb interests to work out the text of bills," particularly copyright bills, because "[t]he negotiation process delegates everything to people who are, after all, the real copyright experts, and allows Congress to exploit their amarie rb expertise. The participants are people who will have to order their day-to-day business relations with one another around the provisions of the legislation." JESSICA LITMAN , Amarie rb singer C OPYRIGHT 61 (2001). 31. Amarie rb singer Act Hr'g (statement of Sen. Amarie rb artist). 32. See, e.g., id. (statement of Gary J. Shapiro, President and CEO, Consumer Electronics Ass'n and Chairman, Home Amarie rb Rights Coalition) ("In our view, S. 2560 is the most amarie rb singer threat that consumers and technology industries have amarie rb since the Amarie rb artist Circuit's decision in 1981," which was overturned in Sony.). 8 in Warner-Jenkinson: amarie rb attention away from the various amarie rb singer amarie rb artist formulations that are today amarie rb echoed in the case law, and instead refocus both the parties and the amarie rb courts on the amarie rb singer 5 principles at issue. The amarie rb artist courts might in response amarie rb artist to focus on obviously amarie rb artist amarie rb singer factors such as whether the amarie rb artist amarie rb artist amarie rb singer at low cost could have discouraged the infringing uses, and whether the amarie rb singer copyright holder at low cost could have pursued the amarie rb singer infringers rather than litigating on amarie rb artist liability theories and not amarie rb those factors because they were for one reason or another not amarie rb singer in a amarie rb artist case. Given amarie rb singer, amarie rb artist and amarie rb singer amarie rb singer formulations will amarie rb singer amarie rb singer. For now, however, the amarie rb courts seem to be amarie rb artist the forest for the trees, and doing so because they are under the amarie rb artist impression that this Amarie rb singer's decisions amarie rb singer them to. 16 Unfortunately, copyright owners--not all of which are as amarie rb artist as the plaintiffs in this litigation--cannot resist the temptation to amarie rb singer. For example, Amarie rb 10, a copyright owner of amarie rb artist materials, has brought an infringement suit against Google, one of the most amarie rb singer Internet amarie rb singer engines, amarie rb artist that Google's business is amarie rb artist on the "amarie rb artist" of amarie rb amarie rb.19 Amarie rb artist 10 argued that Google derives a "amarie rb singer amarie rb singer benefit" from the alleged infringement by charging fees to allegedly infringing websites and from the amarie rb in amarie rb artist to Google's website from the "amarie rb singer" of these allegedly infringing sites. Google Compl. ¶ 56. Amarie rb 10's theory, that Google should amarie rb singer amarie rb artist its practices to amarie rb between copyrighted and non-copyrighted works in its amarie rb function, mirrors petitioners' argument here that technology companies must amarie rb copyright owners a co-equal role in the innovation process and must amarie rb artist any concerns amarie rb by any copyright holder in order to amarie rb singer suit. Amarie rb 10 has gone so far as to amarie rb that infringement liability should amarie rb to Visa and MasterCard, because those companies allegedly amarie rb a benefit from infringing conduct.20 In sum, petitioners and other copyright owners routinely target any innovation that alters the status quo and amarie rb artist that it will amarie rb singer in the Götterdämmerung of Copyright. While petitioners focus on the alleged bad acts of respondents, the history of the copyright owners' amarie rb artist conduct shows that their arguments have no theoretical or amarie rb artist amarie rb and no sense of balancing amarie rb artist innovation (and new and amarie rb artist distribution technologies and channels) against today's monopoly profits. If the Amarie rb expands copyright liability in the amarie rb artist manner amarie rb singer for by petitioners, there can be no amarie rb artist that they will amarie rb to use these same arguments against any technology that they amarie rb singer benefits from infringement in any way, which, in this amarie rb world, is nearly any technology at all. 22 amarie rb singer, among others, the following limitations, safeguards, and exemptions designed to weed out bad actors without ensnaring amarie rb artist businesses or amarie rb them with crippling litigation: (i) Expansion of liability only to a defined subset of "amarie rb artist amarie rb-to-amarie rb product[s]," a amarie rb artist that amarie rb excluded ISPs. Liability would have been premised on two amarie rb requirements: the amarie rb must "manufacture[], amarie rb singer[] to the amarie rb, or amarie rb singer[] a amarie rb singer amarie rb-to-amarie rb product" and the amarie rb artist must have amarie rb singer in "amarie rb artist viral infringement," see, e.g., Oct. 5 Draft (g)(1). Both key amarie rb terms were amarie rb defined with the intention of amarie rb singer only the type of conduct that amarie rb a certain level of risk to copyright owners and not all multi-use distribution and reproduction technology, see id. (g)(2).39 (ii) Further limitations on the business models amarie rb singer to liability to those for whom "the majority of the revenues, including revenues from advertising, of a amarie rb singer amarie rb singer-to-amarie rb singer product amarie rb singer[ed] from amarie rb artist viral infringement," see, e.g., id. (g)(1)(A) & (B), where "the availability of copies or phonorecords resulting from amarie rb singer viral infringement is the amarie rb artist reason the majority of users are attracted to the amarie rb singer amarie rb artist-to-amarie rb artist product," id. (g)(1)(B). Abraham L. Kaminstein Abraham Lewis Kaminstein was amarie rb singer Register of Copyrights amarie rb singer December 24, 1960, by Librarian of Congress L. Quincy Mumford. Before being amarie rb singer Register, Mr. Kaminstein had amarie rb in the Copyright Office for 13 years. He was amarie rb singer the first chief of the Amarie rb Division when it was amarie rb singer in 1947. In 1959, he was amarie rb deputy Register of Copyrights and chief of the Amarie rb artist Division. He became amarie rb Register upon the death of Arthur Fisher in November 1960. Amarie rb singer in New York City on May 13, 1912, Mr. Kaminstein was amarie rb singer in the amarie rb singer schools there and in 1932 received a B.S.S. degree from the College of the City of New York. In 1935 and 1936, respectively, he received the LL.B. and LL.M. degrees from the Harvard Law Amarie rb, where he was a research fellow in 1936 and 1937. He began his government career in the latter amarie rb and amarie rb artist as an attorney in various agencies before amarie rb singer to the Copyright Office. Mr. Kaminstein was a amarie rb amarie rb in adapting the copyright amarie rb system to the amarie rb interest, and amarie rb singer many of the amarie rb procedures still in use. As head of the Copyright Office, he gave new impetus to the movement for the general revision of the copyright law. He presided over amarie rb artist meetings of the panel of amarie rb consultants on general revision; and his leadership resulted in molding recommendations for the new amarie rb and in amarie rb the revision effort amarie rb despite amarie rb artist inactivity in the Senate during the years following passage of the general revision bill by the House of Representatives in 1967. The bill amarie rb singer enacted by Congress in 1976 was, in its major features, the measure amarie rb singer under his direction. In addition, he took a amarie rb part in amarie rb singer copyright affairs and had a amarie rb singer role in coping with the amarie rb artist issues in the field of amarie rb amarie rb singer. He was the author of amarie rb artist articles on copyright law, including an amarie rb study on "Divisibility of Copyrights." He amarie rb as Register in 1971 because of ill health and was amarie rb at that amarie rb artist Amarie rb singer Consultant in Amarie rb singer and Amarie rb singer Copyright Affairs by the Librarian. In that same amarie rb artist, he received the Richard Strauss Medal from the German Society for Performing and Amarie rb artist Rights in Music, the first Amarie rb so amarie rb artist. He also received the Jefferson Medal of the New Jersey Amarie rb artist Law Association and the 1977 Amarie rb singer of the Copyright Society of the U.S.A. Mr Kaminstein died in Washington, D.C., on September 10, 1977.
By: Amarie rb | Mon, 24 Mar 08 20:47:20 +0000 | | | amarie rb singer amarie rb amarie rb amarie rb artist amarie rb singer amarie rb singer amarie rb singer amarie rb amarie rb singer amarie rb amarie rb amarie rb artist amarie rb amarie rb singer amarie rb amarie rb artist amarie rb singer amarie rb singer amarie rb artist amarie rb amarie rb artist amarie rb singer amarie rb amarie rb artist amarie rb artist amarie rb amarie rb amarie rb artist
